Embrace the Null Space (935 Hours)

There is a tendency when we look at a familiar piece of music to see it as a single contiguous object, rather than as a series of moments, each one flowing into the next. However when we look at a new piece of music, especially one with unfamiliar note transitions, something magical happens in our brains. We are forced to disengage our autopilot, slow down, and forge new neural pathways to an untilled plot of mental real estate. Once we find that note, even if the transition is not very clean or accurate, our instinct is to move forward and begin conquering to the next series of notes.

Unfortunately, if an awkward transition between any notes remains neglected, something rather untidy and unmagical begins to take root in our minds. Each time we play that passage, we accumulate a set of awkward sensations that get reinforced through repetition. This now predictable awkwardness turns into disconcerting thoughts, feelings, and judgements so we tune them out as best we can to “focus on the music” and in the process, the transition between the notes gets fuzzier and increasingly chaotic. The result of such practice habits can be disastrous during a performance where unconscious hiccups become magnified as tunnel vision kicks in and our instincts take over.

The best way that I’ve found to banish these subconscious gremlins is to insert a series of rest beats inbetween each note transition in a new piece, and put the section (usually just two notes) on a metronome loop, repeating the transitions over and over again. The rest beats are the key to this exercise because they give the mind time to calculate and the body time to relax and find a graceful path to the next note. Every mistake is an opportunity to examine what can go wrong, and then make a positive reinforcing correction on the next loop. Its important to avoid the temptation to fix the problem mid-loop, or else you’ll be ingraining “note hunting” habits. These are especially heinous because not only do they result in mealy technique, poor intonation, and messy bow-starts, but in a performance setting, the unsteady sounds they produce are often much more apparent to the audience than to the musician.

The reason this rest note exercise seems to work is very similar to the principles of micro muscle movements taught in tai chi. To go fast, you must first go slow. The slower you go, the more information your muscles and nerves have to work with, and the more time you have to declench that vulcan death grip on the fingerboard! Likewise, the more rest beats between the notes, the easier, smoother, and more relaxed your note transitions will ultimately be. I have gone as high as three rest notes. Try it on a short piece of unfamiliar music. You will be amazed when your fingers begin to be drawn, as if by magnetism, to the exact right spot with each metronome click. Once you experience this magical feeling, then you are only just beginning to get a benefit of repetition. To get the full benefit, you will need to wear a mental grove in that string by reinforcing the accurate motions on a daily basis.

This practice technique is so useful and effective that I now devote the first hour (or more) of my practice sessions to this kind of exercise. It’s essentially like scale work, but with an emphasis on accuracy rather than tone. There are similar exercises that I do for tone, but that will be for a future post!


5 thoughts on “Embrace the Null Space (935 Hours)

  1. cellodiary says:

    I am SO glad of your blog. Thanks for sharing this technique: I’m sure I’m going to find it very useful. Your whole mindfulness approach to the cello makes all kinds of sense to me: I get lots of crazy a-ha moments when I’m reading your posts here and the comments you’re kind enough to leave over at my place. I found the articles by Greg Beaver that you linked so timely and pertinent I’ve saved them all and intend to refer back to them often. His “we practice not to get better but to notice more” (I paraphrase and hope I got it right) I have copied into my notebook and keep going back to it to think about what it means. I don’t think I’ve fully understood or absorbed its meaning but something tells me it’s of vital importance. So thanks again and please keep posting!

  2. Thank you for your kind words of encouragement! The lesson I took away from Mr Beaver’s quotable insight is that the accuracy of the ruler by which you measure improvement is the most important practice tool in your arsenal. The more you are capable of noticing, the tighter the notches on your ruler are together. This is especially true on an instrument like the cello with so many continuous variables (fretless intonation, bow pressure, bow speed, contact point, vibrato speed). On other instruments, such as the piano or guitar, the ability to modify the pitch or tambour with your hands is limited or non-existent. On the cello, we have infinitesimal potential for control. So in order to improve, we must first develop our ability to notice (hear) increasingly smaller differences in each of the variables mentioned above, then notice (feel)how they occur, and finally to drill them in with repetition.

  3. Nelson says:

    What do the hours mean next to each post topic? Long time follower.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s